Mary Stayed Out All Night, episodes 1 to 4

Apologies for the inactivity. Life is very all-consuming right now.

I feel like most people who I’ve talked to, when they’re busy and they watch a drama, it’s easier to enjoy it because watching a drama is obviously a source of entertainment and it’s serves as a way to escape temporarily. But I feel like for me, when I’m busy and cranky and exhausted and I have some downtime to relax in front of the computer and I watch a drama, it’s even easier for me to dislike one because I don’t try to make excuses for it, nor do I try too much to reason out why a drama is this way.

Maybe I’m just cranky because this is not turning out the way I want it to, but “Mary” is not working out for me. I am not enjoying any part of this, despite Kim Jae-wook’s overwhelming hotness.

I feel like this is the kind of drama “norm” for Jang Geun-seok — light and funny romantic comedies — but completely a step back for Moon Geun-young and Kim Jae-wook. It’s good that they get to show they have a range in their acting, but their characters are driving me up the wall, and neither one of them so far has allowed the actors to give a more nuanced and subtle performance, which is my biggest problem.

(And just as an aside, I’m not doing caps for this series. Recaps are not my thing, I’ve learned. As someone on my Formspring so nicely coined it for me, I do opinioncaps. And I will probably do opinioncaps til the end of time, so no turn-by-turn episode recaps from me!)

I have to admit that most of the time, how much I like a character really depends on whether or not a character has the traits that I admire and look for in my own friends, or traits I wish I possessed myself. That might not be separating a story from real life and I know a lot of film/TV people would find that kind of analysis problematic because you’re projecting certain things onto the story and then the stories and characters are not their own entities, not free from bias.

On the other hand, isn’t it only natural you analyze the people in stories the way you would to others in real life?

So my problem with Moon Geun-young’s Wi Mae-ri is that I — to put it bluntly — can’t fucking stand people like her.

How much I’m liking Wi Mae-ri is completely separate from how good I think Moon Geun-young is at acting, because there is no need to talk about Moon Geun-young is, because it’s a given that she’s fucking good.

Maybe I will differ from many on this, but I don’t like people who are whimsical, silly, unaware, exaggerated, unsure, shrill. And then in contrast, I do like awareness and decisiveness.

And Wi Mae-ri fits to a T all the traits I don’t like in people. I hate the way she talks, I hate the way she presents herself, I hate the way she interacts with people. Every time she talks to Moo-kyul in an attempt to drive Jung-in out of the picture I just want to punch the living daylights out of something.

This doesn’t mean that I think she’s a bad person or a weak person, I just find it really, really, really hard to connect with her and that makes up a HUGE part of why I don’t like Mae-ri.

The only time I did like Mae-ri, for a split second, was when she spoke up against Seo-joon’s manager for speaking to her in banmal, and telling Seo-joon straight to her face that she misunderstood the incident in the bathroom. I’m a little confused as to how that version of Mae-ri even exists when the Mae-ri from all the other times is such a caricature of the whimsical boho.

For Kim Jae-wook, most of my reservation came from the fact that he’s playing a chaebol again after having just played one a couple of months ago, but that’s really no longer a problem only because there’s the more pressing issue of why he’s so boring and flat as a character. Maybe it’s still too early to tell — and it really shouldn’t be because we’re already 4 hours into this story — but he doesn’t feel like he has much of a personality. He’s such a sluggish character right now that I can’t even work myself up to imagine how there can be conflict between him and Jang Geun-seok’s Moo-kyul. They would only be rivals on a superficial sense, where Moo-kyul’s free-spirited ways clash with Jung-in’s business-like approaches and that’s really uninteresting to me.

And then aside from that, I find this whole story to be kind of ridiculous right now, and like I said before, when I’m grumpy I don’t try to justify the ridiculousness. I’m just gonna let it rip:

- The circumstances under which Mae-ri met Moo-kyul are ridiculous. What’s even more ridiculous is why she continued to follow him, and the way she acted as she did follow him.

- The two marriage contracts. This is so stupid and they don’t even try to make it look not stupid.

- Jang Geun-seok pretending to be a rock star. I love JGS with a good portion of my heart but he always came off as really poserish whenever he tried to act like he was a musician, and he’s done it so many times now I’m afraid he really thinks of himself as a musician. Boy, you are not.

- How Mae-ri is styled turns me off SO badly. I just wanna rip off all her extensions and straight that friggin’ poof.

- Jung-in and Mae-ri being childhood friends and both of them not remembering…til a photograph resurfaces…with Japanese written on it…which translates to one of the cheesiest and most cliched things you can write on a photograph in an Asian drama… I just can’t. I feel like I need some kind of gif to represent my emotions right now.

So…verdict on this one ain’t great. But I’m going to stick with it for a while to see how it goes because I DO really love this cast, and these actors/actresses don’t seem to come around too often in these drama parts (minus Jang), so I should stick with it.

  • Cherry

    The Mae-ri character is the exact same reason why I’m having trouble liking the show. Jang Geun-suk and Moon Geun-young have amazing chemistry but whenever Geun-young acts sweet and quirky (i.e. nearly every drama she’s ever been in) I want to punch her in the face. That loud, bug-eyed cutesy act drives me nuts! lol

    Oh and I know everyone raves about Moon Geun-young’s acting but I think she overacts most of the time, tbh.

    Reply

    Amy Reply:

    Did you skip “Cinderella’s Sister”? Hahaha, she was definitely not cute and quirky in that. And I think the overexaggeration in this drama is part of the character, but I might be biased! :P

    Reply

    Cherry Reply:

    No, I haven’t watched it yet but I do know she acts more serious in it.

    I do like Geun-young when she plays more serious roles (like in Painter of the Wind, for example), but the cute stuff drives me bonkers. haha I think it’s all the huge gestures and weird faces she makes (which is what I meant by overacting).

    Reply

  • Alixana

    So far, I’m feeling a bit let down with the drama (especially Kim Jaewok’s character – he’s sooooo fucking boring), but I’ll keep watching it because I have a huge soft spot for MGY.

    Reply

  • pengork

    tbh i was tickled pink with the first 2 eps and i liked the second two not as much but a lot. mae-ri’s loud annoying ‘CHAGIYAS’ were the only times i really got mad at her, although i wasn’t happy with her letting off her father so easily either. i love that the girl’s got sense: she’s in a stupid situation but she isn’t going to choose either of them! fuck ‘em all she’s going to college! that plus her reaction to seo joon + moon geun young’s faces [when he said she looks like a girl and she said she is one; when she was creeping over to check out jung-in's gay partner] means i adore her. as long as we get rid of the chagiyas quickly.

    jang geun seok is awesome. what i love about their pre-romance relationship is that they’re acting like two people who have gotten to know each other. the typical pre-romance relationship is dislike/clashing mixed with awareness of each other, or politeness until the /feelings/ start creeping up. i loved the line in the police station when she started speaking informally to him, the way he randomly loled at her when he said she was like shrek’s kitty. i love the nature of their relationship pre *~feelings~*

    as for the stupidity of their first meeting, the two contracts et al – it’s not pretending it’s not ridiculous, and that’s what makes it hilarious in how nuts it is. the meta element is fun. three piggybacks in four episodes! but i guess it’s not for everyone. i have a pretty high tolerance for this stuff so i’m eating it up.

    shame about kim jae wook. :c

    Reply

  • http://misslame.com esther

    Am I the only one who doesn’t find Jang Geun Seok attractive, or consider his acting to be good? To me he seems really wooden, and his range (or lack of) expressions are starting to look the same in every single drama. Maybe it’s because he thinks a musician should be acting all ‘cool’ or what not, but I don’t really find it easy to watch.
    I actually don’t mind Moon Geun Young’s portrayal of Mary, although it does get a little bit shrill sometimes. She breathes some sort of life into her character, while JGS and Kim Jae Wook are really….boring.

    Reply

    mintyboy Reply:

    Actually, I’m with you on our small boat. I don’t think the two leads were cast properly. Not to say that they can’t act, but that their strength lies in more serious and heavy roles, not the “sweet” and wtf they’re pulling here. Not only is the whole show too saccharine, I can see the “acting” that they’re doing and everything is such a turn off after episode 3 (save for KJW because his character wasn’t over the top).
    The storyline isn’t helping either. This is seriously annoying and insulting since it’s just fluff passing off as “trendy.” i haven’t read the comics, but from the title, I was expecting something more edgy/street-ish(?) rather than this mess of a lame attempt.
    Lol, finally, yes Amy, rip her hair off. The girl is already petite, adding more poundage on her head will only diminish her already small face and body (but I do love her collection of bags though). On that note, please buy a new wardrobe for EVERYONE as well! All of them are trying too hard to look effortless that they become caricatures of what they should look like. To paraphrase Javabean, Seonjoon does look like a hooker in her off-duty attires. Ok, out of breathe, no more ranting.

    Reply

  • holycow!

    agreed.
    I’m kinda unsure about the mae-ri character.
    like what exactly is she? she’s supposed to be 24 but she acts like a high school student and is styled rather young (on top of the fact that moon geun young does look much much younger than she is). her hair overpowers her whole image and luckily she had it tied up for the most recent episode.
    why does the cool rocker dude hang out with the whimsical girl?
    and whenever I see jung in with mae-ri, it looks like something illegal…

    but then, I think this show has its redeeming qualities. both leads have really aww-inducing interactions and I like that quirky track they use when it comes to comical moments. The one that sounds like a video game.
    and then there’s the scene in which jung in walks down the back alley with shades and moo-kyul’s guitar. i was like OMG!! OMG!! OMG!!

    Reply

  • http://bechedor79.deviantart.com/ bechedor79

    This is completely off-topic since I’m reading recaps of this show but really don’t have any desire to watch it, BUT. If you happen to watch Secret Garden, I would love to see what your opinioncap of that might be. I’m constantly refreshing various sites now, desperately wishing for subs to be uploaded on any given refresh.

    Reply

    bechedor79 Reply:

    Uh, “this show” meaning Mary Stayed Out All Night. Am DEFINITELY watching Secret Garden (despite the unfortunate name).

    Reply

    Amy Reply:

    Ha! I’ve actually been marathoning Secret Garden all night. Definitely like Secret Garden over Mary right now.

    Reply

    bechedor79 Reply:

    Oh, excellent! I hope we get to see you post about it at some point. :D

    Reply

  • tiacosas

    “- The circumstances under which Mae-ri met Moo-kyul are ridiculous. What’s even more ridiculous is why she continued to follow him, and the way she acted as she did follow him.”

    I knew this drama wasn’t made for me when I saw Mae Ri following him frantically. I just ughh.

    The fact that the chaebol is bo-ring and the musician is ridiculous, doesn’t help.

    Considering I ff most of episodes 1 and 2, it’s likely I won’t continue watching this (or maybe I’ll keep on ff-ing 90% of the episodes, just to see what happens), as they say, life’s too short to spend it watching bad dramas.

    Funnily enough, I agree with everything you said ^^

    Reply

  • Sara

    at last a review on M3 that I agree on…. maybe I’ve put too much hope on M3 so the end result is so dissapointing and watching the fabulous SKKS followed by M3 makes M3′s weakness more glaring… I’ve plowed through to episode 5 because of my love for Geun Suk but even he can’t save the show for me ….can’t connect with Maeri and totally agree with styling…cute at first with the poofy Bardot doll hair and all but later on I just want to get a scissor to chop it all off and can’t stand that both of them allowing themselves to be manipulated by other people…Maeri by her father and Moo Kyul by Mae Ri , his mother , and later on in eps 5 the manager ….

    btw Secret Garden is love….wonderful so far… though it is too early to say with just 4 episodes in… hopefully it will not be inflicted by k drama disease of sluggish halfway

    Reply